A place to share my thoughts and reflections

Tumblr ↗

Tag: education

  • Before You Judge the Vanua, First Understand It

    The debate over the Bose Levu Vakaturaga reveals a deeper question: have we learned to live together without learning to understand one another?

    We speak confidently of multi-culturalism, equal citizenship and national unity. Yet when discussion turns to the BLV, many inhabit different worlds of understanding.

    The issue is not simply whether chiefs have a place in our constitutional arrangements. It is whether those who pronounce upon the Vanua understand the civilisation, language and customary relationships from which its institutions emerged. Language is the most revealing place to begin.

    A Lesson From Kenya

    I lived in Kenya for more than a decade, and the contrast is instructive. Many Kenyans of Indian descent speak Swahili, not because they are inherently more culturally sensitive, but because history, commerce and daily interaction made it a practical bridge between communities. After independence, Swahili also became an instrument of national identity.

    Fiji followed a different path. Colonial policies encouraged communities to develop in largely separate social and linguistic worlds. English became the language of government, law, education and commerce, while Fiji Hindi and vosa vakaViti remained central to our respective communities.

    That inheritance helps explain why many non-iTaukei, including prominent political, business and intellectual figures, can spend their lives in Fiji without acquiring much understanding of vosa vakaViti. But explanation should not become an excuse, particularly for those who seek to influence the affairs of the indigenous people.

    One can read the Constitution, debate customary land or pronounce on chiefly institutions without understanding the relationships and obligations that give the Vanua its meaning. There is a difference between knowing about the iTaukei and understanding the iTaukei.

    Two Understandings of Belonging

    Much of our disagreement arises from different understandings of what it means to belong to a nation. One sees Fiji through a modern civic framework: equal citizenship, individual rights, parliamentary representation and the rule of law. The other also recognises an inherited covenant: the enduring relationship between people, land, ancestry, customary authority and obligations passed between generations.

    For the iTaukei, the Vanua is not simply territory. It embodies identity, belonging, responsibility and continuity.

    These understandings need not contradict each other. Our challenge is to hold both within a constitutional democracy that guarantees equal citizenship while recognising the distinctive place of its indigenous people.

    Respect Is Not Submission

    Nowhere is the gap wider than on the question of chiefs and personal freedom. Two views stand in plain opposition.

    The first begins with the individual. It holds that inherited hierarchy and personal autonomy cannot coexist, and that authority no one has voted for answers to no one. If people can speak for themselves, why do they need chiefs? On this view, the Vanua is a constraint, and the indigenous citizen must eventually choose between his/her chief and his/her own mind.

    The second begins with the relationship. It rejects the choice itself. The Vanua, it says, is not a chain of command but a web of kinship, obligation and service. The people sustain chiefly leadership; chiefs carry duties towards those they serve. Respect is given within that bond, not extracted by force. An iTaukei may honour his chief and still vote against his preferences, and our electoral history shows that indigenous voters do exactly that.

    One view measures freedom by what a person is released from. The other measures it by what a person belongs to. Each hears the other’s vocabulary as either bondage or abandonment, and neither will persuade the other while both speak past it.

    Authority can be misused in any institution, but the possibility of misuse does not invalidate the foundations of the institution itself. An iTaukei should not have to abandon the Vanua to prove his or her independence, any more than any citizen should abandon faith or tradition to prove freedom of thought.

    Multi-culturalism Must Be Reciprocal

    Our leaders frequently speak of multi-culturalism and inclusion. But it cannot mean that indigenous institutions must continually justify their existence while other traditions are accepted as legitimate expressions of identity. Nor should iTaukei be expected to master the language and conventions of modern political and commercial life, while those who wish to influence indigenous affairs feel little obligation to understand the Vanua.

    Reciprocity matters. The iTaukei should understand the history of indenture, the struggles of Indo-Fijians for political equality and the anxieties of our national upheavals. Equally, non-iTaukei citizens, particularly those in positions of influence, should make a serious effort to understand the history, language and customary institutions of the indigenous people.

    This is not a demand for assimilation, nor for fluency in vosa vakaViti before participating in national affairs. It is a call for intellectual humility and cultural curiosity. The business leader negotiating with landowners, the lawyer interpreting customary rights, the academic and the politician debating the BLV should recognise that professional expertise alone does not provide a complete understanding of the Vanua.

    Understanding should precede judgment.

    The BLV Is Not Another Parliament

    The BLV is frequently discussed as though it were a competing political institution. It is not. Its authority does not originate from elections or the government of the day. It comes from the Vanua and the customary relationships that have sustained indigenous society across generations. Its concern is the enduring interests of the iTaukei: cultural inheritance, customary institutions, land and collective wellbeing.

    Governments come and go. Parties rise and fall. Majorities change. The Vanua endures. That is why the BLV’s institutional independence matters: the protection of indigenous identity should not depend solely on the goodwill of whichever party holds office.

    Parliament represents citizens through elections. The BLV embodies a distinct sphere of indigenous customary leadership. These roles need not conflict. The BLV is a shield for the Vanua, not a sword against fellow citizens. Its recognition diminishes neither the citizenship nor the dignity of Indo-Fijians, Rotumans or any other community. It acknowledges that our indigenous civilisation possesses institutions whose legitimacy cannot be measured solely through the ballot box.

    Language Carries a Civilisation

    Vosa vakaViti carries memory, relationships, obligations, authority and ways of understanding the world. Concepts such as Vanua, veiwekani, veirogorogoci, veidokai and veiliutaki cannot be captured by literal English translation. Their meanings emerge through lived relationships and customary practice. Those who discuss the BLV without appreciating them, risk treating a living cultural institution as just another administrative body.

    This matters not because fluency confers wisdom, but because willingness to learn another community’s language often reflects willingness to understand its world. We cannot expect meaningful national dialogue when those most confident in judging indigenous institutions have made little effort to understand their foundations.

    Understanding Before Judgment

    For too long, we have confused co-existence with understanding. We have worked in the same institutions, attended the same schools and voted in the same elections, yet we have not always made the effort to understand how our fellow citizens perceive belonging. The BLV debate exposes that unfinished work.

    Those who declare the institution obsolete should first ask whether they understand its purpose. Those who argue Fiji survived without it under the previous regime, should consider whether administrative survival is an adequate measure of cultural progress. A nation can keep functioning while losing its connection to its historical identity.

    Equal citizenship does not require cultural sameness, and respect for indigenous institutions does not diminish anyone else’s citizenship. We belong to one nation, but our historical journeys differ. Understanding those differences should strengthen our common citizenship, not threaten it.

    Perhaps the most important question is not whether Fiji can survive without its chiefs, but whether it can truly understand itself while unwilling to understand the language, institutions and inherited obligations of the people whose homeland gave the nation its name.

    We have spent generations learning to speak to one another in English. Perhaps it is time we learned to understand one another through the languages and cultures of our shared homeland.

    For the Vanua does not need to justify its existence to those who have yet to understand it.

  • AI Can Answer. The Human Must Still Think.

    The crisis facing our universities—that AI detection can no longer reliably establish whether submitted work reflects a student’s own knowledge—is not merely technical. It is part of a broader reckoning in education, including medical schools, where the line between a student’s reasoning and AI-generated output is increasingly difficult to police.

    Our Higher Education Commission has admitted that existing AI-detection systems are “no longer reliably doing the job.” That exposes a weakness in traditional assessment: the assumption that a finished product proves the thinking behind it.

    Better detection software will not solve this. A better algorithm may simply raise the cost of evasion; it does not restore trust. The question is not how to detect AI. It is how to rethink authentic learning itself.

    This is what an OB, Taniela calls “Human in the Loop.” In Star Trek, the ship’s computer scans millions of variables and offers an analysis, but the decision on the next move belongs to the crew—their ethics, their context, their judgment. The machine provides intelligence; the humans provide power and accountability. In the classroom, if we ask only “What” and “How”—lower-order cognitive tasks—we train students to be the computer. AI already does that. We must ask questions that require analysis, evaluation, synthesis and creation.

    Consider a simple example. A dalo crop is not growing well. Soil pH, nutrient deficiencies, weather, and local farming practices all interact. Students with basic knowledge can test the soil, run results through AI to explore possible deficiencies and natural local solutions, then design a cause-and-effect experiment to find what works. In one exercise they find facts, apply Bloom’s highest levels, think scientifically, and make collaborative decisions based on evidence. That is authentic learning. That is the human in the loop.

    Medical education faces a parallel question: how do we assess a future doctor’s judgment when a diagnostic note, treatment plan or patient summary may be generated or shaped by AI? The concern goes beyond cheating. Educators are discussing de-skilling among experienced clinicians and “never-skilling” or “mis-skilling” among students who rely on AI before essential capabilities have developed. A student may produce a sophisticated diagnosis with AI assistance yet struggle to explain the reasoning at the bedside. That gap is precisely what assessment must expose.

    This is not an argument against AI. AI is a profound game changer, transforming how we work, learn, communicate and make decisions. China’s open-sourcing of AI models is precisely aimed at lifting its people out of poverty faster. When AI is open, a student in Fiji can use the same analytical power as a student in Xiamen to solve a localized problem—and then apply the contextual wisdom only a Fijian farmer or village elder can provide. That is technology democratized, human context elevated.

    Yet the AI industry’s own confidence often rests on an unspoken assumption: that intelligence is all you need. As Gautam Mukunda argues in Bloomberg Opinion, Sam Altman’s vision assumes that if you are smart enough, you can cure cancer or destroy the world. But that is not how power and intelligence work. Intelligence thrives where feedback is fast and clear: mathematics, coding, games. In medicine, education, ethics and human affairs however, feedback is slow, context is thick, and consequences are delayed. There, intelligence must be paired with power—infrastructure, resources, experience and the accumulated judgment that only lived consequences can teach. AI can supply the former; it cannot supply the latter.

    AI can be a tutor, simulator, drafting partner and source of instant feedback. But it cannot be the student.

    For me, this is personal. I have spent more than 50 years traveling, working and learning across Australia, NZ, the Americas, Africa, the Middle East, Asia and Europe. Those experiences gave me a reservoir of knowledge, context and human encounters that shapes how I think and use AI. When I ask AI a question, I do not approach its answer from a blank page. I can test what it tells me against what I have seen, experienced and learned over decades. I do not fear AI’s answers as much as I fear the absence of the inner library against which those answers are judged.

    That distinction concerns me when I think about my grandchildren. They are growing up in a world where AI can produce an apparently authoritative answer before they have acquired the knowledge and experience to question it. The danger is not simply that they may use AI to avoid homework. It is that they may outsource the very process through which judgment is formed. They may learn to prompt before they learn to ponder.

    An answer can be technically correct and still be wrong for the circumstances. Context, history, culture and human behaviour matter. Knowing what to ask—and recognising when a convincing answer does not make sense—often comes from accumulated experience, not information alone. Without that inner library, fluency with AI can masquerade as understanding.

    AI can extend human capability enormously, but it cannot give a young person decades of lived experience. That experience still has to be acquired.

    This is why the challenge facing universities and medical schools is larger than AI detection. It is whether education will continue to develop people who can think, rather than merely produce answers. That requires more oral examinations, supervised work, iterative drafts, practical demonstrations, reflective explanation and problem-solving under observation. Portfolios that track revisions, oral defenses that probe reasoning and supervised tasks requiring live problem-solving can make thinking visible.

    This is not a rejection of technology. It is about ensuring technology does not displace the intellectual development education is meant to cultivate. The institutions that adapt will be those willing to rethink assessment: moving from policing outputs to observing process, from assuming competence to demonstrating it, and from asking whether a student produced an answer to asking whether the student can explain, challenge and own the thinking behind it.

    The goal is not to make AI invisible. It is to make human judgment visible.

    The real educational challenge of the AI age is not whether our children learn to use AI. They must. It is whether, in learning to use it, they also learn when to question it, when to challenge it—and when to think for themselves.