Ms Lenora Qereqeretabua raises concerns that many share. Vandalism, violence and attacks on places of worship are unacceptable. No community should have to endure them, and parents, families and communities have responsibilities they cannot abdicate.
But holding individuals accountable is fundamentally different from holding an entire people responsible for the misconduct of a few. When an iTaukei child misbehaves, why must an entire community be summoned to account? Why this inclination to collectivise failure?
Honest criticism, whether from within a community or beyond it, is essential to a healthy society. The question is whether such criticism seeks to understand and resolve a problem or merely to apportion blame. Sweeping generalisations risk reinforcing the very prejudices our people have long struggled against.
I wonder whether Ms Qereqeretabua’s political positioning has influenced the lens through which she now views iTaukei society. Her political affiliation is entirely her democratic right. It neither diminishes her iTaukei identity nor disqualifies her from challenging our people. But surely political allegiance should broaden one’s understanding of the society one seeks to serve, rather than narrow it.
Our Vanua, lotu and cultural institutions are not beyond criticism. They, too, must confront their shortcomings. Yet they remain important sources of identity, responsibility, belonging and mutual obligation. Surely these are institutions to engage as partners in social renewal, rather than invoke primarily as objects of public rebuke.
And while parental responsibility is indispensable, what of the wider circumstances confronting our families? Poverty, educational disengagement, unemployment, substance abuse and weakening community support structures are not uniquely iTaukei problems. They are national challenges requiring more than admonishment directed at one community.
Nor is concern about discipline new. During the Constitutional Review Commission consultations, many Vanua submissions called for the restoration of corporal punishment as a response to what they perceived as declining discipline among young people. Whatever one’s views on corporal punishment, those submissions reflected genuine community anxieties and a desire to restore order and accountability.
The wisdom of the proposed remedy is open to debate. The concerns that prompted it should not be dismissed.
These circumstances do not excuse misconduct. But they raise questions that responsible political leadership cannot afford to overlook. What is being done to strengthen families, support schools, address youth disengagement and equip communities to confront these challenges? And are these priorities receiving the sustained attention they deserve in Parliament?
There is a difference between speaking about one’s people and speaking for their wellbeing. The former may require little more than indignation. The latter demands empathy, accountability, cultural understanding and the willingness to confront uncomfortable social and institutional realities.
No cultural identity confers a licence to condemn an entire people for the wrongdoing of individuals. Equally, no community should be shielded from fair criticism simply because of its identity. Both principles deserve defending.
Perhaps, then, the more constructive question is not simply, “iTaukei parents, guardians and grown-ups, where are you?”
It is also one our elected representatives might reasonably ask themselves:
“Where have we, as political leaders, been while these problems have taken root, and what have we actually done to address them?”
Expressing disappointment in one’s people is relatively easy. Accepting responsibility for helping them overcome their difficulties demands considerably more.
The former may attract applause. The latter is the measure of leadership.