A place to share my thoughts and reflections

Tumblr ↗

The Scapegoat Syndrome: A Reflection on Fiji’s Political Malaise

The reported resignation of SODELPA GS Levi Vere has reignited demands that the party deal decisively with two senior lawyers at the centre of the freehold land controversy. For some, the solution seems simple: remove the troublemakers, restore discipline, return to business as usual. The Management Board is reportedly meeting soon over the matter.

But are we reading the story correctly? Or is this another familiar episode in our political culture, where finding someone to blame substitutes for confronting the underlying problem?

There is a difference between accountability and scapegoating. Parties are right to insist on discipline, sound judgment and coherent messaging. But discipline must not become an excuse for suppressing uncomfortable questions, especially those touching the historical foundations of our nation.

The two lawyers have been labelled political rogues. Yet their intervention concerned one of Fiji’s most sensitive questions: land acquired in circumstances that still generate grievances among landowners. The proposal may be economically difficult, legally complicated and politically contentious. It deserves scrutiny. But the proper response is to examine the arguments, separate legitimate grievances from impractical remedies, and explain where the proposals succeed or fail.

Equally, those raising sensitive matters must answer for how they communicate them. In a multiracial society, careless language about land can revive anxieties that responsible leaders should calm, not inflame. Courage and judgment must travel together.

So the question is not whether the lawyers should be held accountable. It is whether accountability is being pursued to resolve a problem or merely to silence an embarrassment. Fiji has a habit of treating individuals as the problem when the real difficulties are structural, historical and institutional.

Consider our position as iTaukei. More than half a century after independence, we still operate within legal, administrative and economic frameworks shaped by our colonial inheritance. The iTaukei collectively own most of Fiji’s land, yet many indigenous communities remain economically disadvantaged. Why has customary ownership not translated into prosperity? Why do financial institutions struggle to lend against customary land’s economic potential without compromising ownership? Why do landowners so often remain passive recipients of lease income rather than equity partners? And why have successive governments failed to undertake the reforms needed to unlock indigenous economic participation?

These questions cannot be answered by expelling two lawyers, nor by the familiar ritual of naming villains, demanding resignations and declaring the matter closed. The underlying problem remains untouched, and the waters only get muddier.

The freehold controversy gave SODELPA a chance to show leadership: acknowledge historical grievances, reassure existing property owners, distinguish lawful remedies from political rhetoric, and advance practical proposals for economic empowerment. Instead, the conversation is consumed by personalities, disciplinary demands and political survival. A party’s relevance should be measured not by the controversies it survives but by the solutions it offers. A party struggling for electoral relevance cannot afford to confuse silence with unity or conformity with competence.

Still, this malaise extends well beyond SODELPA. Even the Prime Minister’s dismissal of the proposal as “misguided”, coming from people who have never been in government, answers the messenger rather than the argument. Across our political landscape, too many leaders are more comfortable managing controversies than confronting their causes. We debate personalities instead of policies, punish dissent instead of examining arguments, and mistake political theatre for decisive leadership. Meanwhile poverty persists, opportunity remains uneven, and the institutional reforms that would turn our resources into broad-based prosperity are deferred again and again. Our political discourse grows louder while our national vision grows smaller.

None of this means historical grievances justify threatening existing rights, or that indigenous advancement must come at another community’s expense. Fiji’s future depends on reconciling historical justice with legal certainty, economic opportunity and equal citizenship. That requires leaders who explain difficult truths without exploiting fear, parties willing to challenge outdated institutions, and voters who judge leaders by their solutions rather than by how many people they discipline.

Fiji does not lack grievances. We lack the political maturity to confront them without turning them into weapons. The real test of leadership is not how quickly a party finds someone to blame, but whether it has the intellectual courage and moral authority to address the issues that made the controversy possible.

We can keep demanding sacrifices and celebrating each new scalp, or we can insist that our leaders face the harder questions of land, economic empowerment, institutional reform and national reconciliation. One approach produces headlines. The other might produce progress.

Until Fiji learns to tell accountability from scapegoating, we will keep changing the faces while preserving the failures.