A window lets us see beyond ourselves. A mirror reflects only what we already carry within.
For Christians in the Pasifika; and I count myself among them, the question is whether Jerusalem has become a window through which we encounter the Almighty and our fellow human beings, or a mirror reflecting inherited beliefs, political loyalties and prejudices.
It is uncomfortable to ask, particularly when faith becomes entangled with foreign policy. But spiritual maturity demands discernment, not unquestioning acceptance of inherited interpretations.
When Theology Becomes Foreign Policy
Fiji opened its embassy in Jerusalem in September 2025. Israel reciprocated in June 2026, establishing its first resident diplomatic mission in the Pasifika, in Suva. This was more than routine diplomacy. During the 2022 coalition negotiations, SODELPA made a Jerusalem embassy a central demand, and Christian organisations such as the International Christian Embassy Jerusalem have long promoted religious and political identification with Israel.
Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka maintains that the decision rested on national interest, not religion. Yet Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar described the relationship in terms of shared biblical roots and an alliance between Jewish and Christian believers. Where does religious conviction end and independent foreign-policy judgement begin?
Israel has real expertise in agriculture, water, health and technology, and Fiji has every reason to seek cooperation. But technological achievement confers no moral immunity, and development assistance should not replace principled scrutiny.
The modern State of Israel, established in 1948, is not synonymous with biblical Israel. One is a sovereign political entity accountable under international law; the other holds a profound place in Jewish and Christian sacred history. Christians may differ over the covenant’s theological significance, but no interpretation places a modern government’s conduct beyond moral examination. A biblical covenant cannot become a blank cheque.
An Icon or an Idol?
In Christian tradition, an icon points beyond itself towards the divine. An idol demands devotion to itself.
The biblical prophets confronted ancient Israel’s rulers when they abandoned justice, oppressed the vulnerable or placed power above righteousness. Fidelity to the Almighty required criticism of wrongdoing, not silence.
Yet some expressions of Christian Zionism risk turning theological attachment into unconditional political allegiance. When criticism of the Israeli government is treated as hostility towards Christianity, reverence for the sacred is confused with loyalty to a state. The Pacific Conference of Churches has questioned religious narratives that mobilise political support for Israel, and its General Secretary, Reverend James Bhagwan, has warned against distorting theology for political purposes.
Idolatry is not confined to carved images. It arises whenever we elevate a nation, government or leader beyond moral scrutiny. When vesumona replaces discernment, faith becomes ideology.
The Vanua Understands What Land Means
For the iTaukei, land is not merely a commodity. The Vanua encompasses people, genealogy, customary authority, spiritual belonging and obligations across generations. Our identity is inseparable from the land and waters entrusted to our care.
Dispossession is more than the loss of territory. It severs relationships, disrupts ancestral continuity and diminishes a people’s capacity to determine their future. That understanding should make us sensitive to Palestinian experience.
The United Nations has repeatedly raised concerns about Israeli settlement expansion, displacement and restrictions on Palestinians in the occupied territories. A UN Commission of Inquiry concluded in 2025 that Israel committed genocide in Gaza; Israel rejects that finding. The International Court of Justice has separately considered allegations under the Genocide Convention but has not issued a final judgement on the merits.
These distinctions matter, but they cannot obscure the suffering. Destroyed homes, displaced families and civilian deaths demand moral attention regardless of nationality or religion.
Asked about human rights concerns surrounding the relationship, Prime Minister Rabuka reportedly said these matters were “none of our business”. If accurately reported, that response deserves reconsideration. If we expect the world to understand the sacred bond between the iTaukei and our Vanua, we must understand Palestinians’ attachment to their homeland.
Two Peoples, One Land
An honest discussion must acknowledge Jewish history. Jewish people have an ancient religious, cultural and historical connection to the land, and centuries of persecution, culminating in the Holocaust, give their concerns about security and survival particular urgency. Neither these realities nor Palestinian identity, historical attachment and aspirations for self-determination can be dismissed. Recognising one does not require denying the other.
Hamas’s atrocities against civilians on 7 October 2023 must be condemned. So must unlawful attacks on Palestinian civilians, collective punishment and forced displacement. These are not competing moral obligations. Every human life possesses equal dignity.
Israelis deserve security. Palestinians deserve freedom, dignity and meaningful self-determination. Neither can be permanently secured by denying the other. The tragedy begins when one people’s suffering becomes the justification for inflicting suffering on another.
Jerusalem: From Wonder to Understanding
As a boy attending church in Honiara in 1962, I imagined Jerusalem as a heavenly city whose golden streets joined earth to the divine. In 1979, I walked its ancient streets, touched the Western Wall and followed the Via Dolorosa, approaching each place with wonder.
Later experiences in West Asia, including years of United Nations service, showed me the political realities behind the sacred geography. I have faced Israeli soldiers at checkpoints and shared meals with Palestinian fathers. I came to understand that holy land remains land, subject to ambition, insecurity, competing claims and human failure.
Jerusalem’s holiness cannot rest on ancient stones alone. Surely it must also be measured by how people treat one another upon that land.
My faith did not disappear; my understanding matured. I began to ask whether the Jerusalem of my childhood imagination had sometimes kept me from seeing its living inhabitants.
The Colonised Mind and Borrowed Convictions
Long before missionaries arrived, our ancestors held spiritual traditions, moral codes and obligations to the vanua and to future generations. Christianity profoundly transformed our societies, but it did not introduce spirituality to spiritually empty peoples. Yet colonialism sometimes taught us that wisdom, legitimacy and spiritual authority must come from elsewhere. We learned to revere distant sacred geography while neglecting responsibilities at home, and memorised biblical genealogies while losing the spiritual meaning of our own.
This is the vesumona of the colonised mind: the persuasion that truth and holiness require validation from somewhere else. The challenge is to distinguish the Gospel from the colonial assumptions and political ideologies attached to it.
A people may achieve political sovereignty while remaining intellectually and spiritually dependent. Perhaps that is one of the unfinished struggles of Pasifika decolonisation.
What Spiritual Maturity Demands
Supporters of Fiji’s relationship with Israel reasonably argue that diplomacy is not endorsement, that cooperation brings tangible benefits, and that Christian affection for Israel need not be political. These arguments deserve consideration. Fiji has also expressed support for a two-state solution and for Palestinian aspirations, but commitments must be reflected in diplomatic conduct.
Our Ocean of Peace cannot mean one standard for powerful friends and another for vulnerable peoples.
If we defend indigenous self-determination in West Papua and Kanaky, we must recognise the same principle in Palestine. If we condemn antisemitism, we must equally condemn Islamophobia and anti-Arab prejudice. If we invoke international law against climate injustice, we cannot treat it as optional when others seek its protection.
Our governments should be free to cooperate with every country, and free to question any of them. Our churches must likewise distinguish Christian faith from political allegiance. Spiritual maturity does not mean exchanging one flag for another. It means questioning all flags against the same moral principles.
The Window or the Mirror?
Ultimately, this debate is not simply about where Fiji places an embassy. It concerns the Christianity we practise, our independence of judgement and the moral inheritance we leave future generations.
Do we look towards Jerusalem and see sacred history calling us towards justice, humility and compassion? Or merely political alliances sanctified through selective readings of Scripture?
The biblical prophets did not ask whether their criticism would please the powerful. Neither should we. Our ancestral traditions remind us that belonging carries obligations, and the Gospel gathers them into one command: love your neighbour.
Nowhere in the New Testament does Jesus say “worship me”. He says “follow me”. To follow him is to walk towards the neighbour, Palestinian and Israeli alike, rather than defend a flag, a government or a map. Surely these truths should enlarge our moral imagination, not narrow it.
A colonised mind looks elsewhere for permission to believe. A liberated mind has the courage to believe, question and act with moral independence. Perhaps the renewal of Pasifika Christianity must begin not in defending distant political projects, but in rediscovering our ancestral wisdom and the courage to follow Christ in serving humanity.
For the question is no longer simply whether we believe in the Almighty. It is whether our faith remains a window through which we see the dignity of others, or has become a mirror in which we worship ourselves.