A place to share my thoughts and reflections

Tumblr ↗

  • When the Military Calls for Accountability: A Test of Constitutional Maturity

    The RFMF Commander’s submission on constitutional immunity challenges Fiji to confront its past and build a democracy grounded in accountability, indigenous recognition and the rule of law.

    The submission by Republic of Fiji Military Forces Commander Major-General Ro Jone Kalouniwai to the Special Parliamentary Committee reviewing Constitution Amendment Bill No. 32 of 2026 may prove a defining moment in Fiji’s constitutional journey.

    The Commander called for the removal of constitutional immunity and proposed a framework for truth, accountability and reconciliation.

    Coming from an institution central to Fiji’s constitutional upheavals, his position deserves serious reflection.

    For decades, immunity has been defended as the price of restoring stability after unconstitutional changes of government. Yet those who suffered intimidation, displacement, violence and economic loss were afforded no comparable protection.

    When the military itself questions this imbalance, the justification for permanent immunity becomes increasingly difficult to sustain.

    The Commander’s submission does not absolve the RFMF of its history. Its significance lies in recognising that military legitimacy derives from service under the Constitution, not from the capacity to intervene when civilian politics becomes dysfunctional.

    Such principles must outlast individual Commanders.

    The Prime Minister’s Unfortunate Reminder

    There was a striking irony before the Commander’s presentation.

    Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka spoke of constructing a Constitution that would endure for generations. Then, addressing the Commander, he remarked:

    “Because if things go wrong, either you or your successor will have to bring it back to order.”

    Perhaps he intended to emphasise the military’s responsibility for national stability. But context matters.

    Mr Rabuka led Fiji’s 1987 coups. He understands the consequences of crossing the boundary between military authority and civilian government.

    His words were therefore particularly ill-judged.

    Constitutional disagreements belong in Parliament, legal disputes in the courts, and political judgments with the electorate. The military has no independent mandate to correct civilian political outcomes.

    Indeed, proposed section 151 of the Government’s own Bill places the RFMF under civilian authority and confines its responsibilities to defence and legally authorised assistance.

    It is a remarkable irony that the serving Commander should be questioning the constitutional legacy of military intervention while a former coup leader, now Prime Minister, still invokes the military’s possible role in restoring order.

    Constitutional maturity requires abandoning not merely unconstitutional conduct, but the assumptions that once normalised it.

    The Contradiction Within the Bill

    Bill No. 32 declares constitutional supremacy and prohibits unconstitutional attempts to establish government. Proposed section 2(6) rejects immunity for such future actions.

    Yet Chapter 14 preserves extensive immunity arising from earlier political upheavals.

    Section 207 seeks to shield those protections from amendment and judicial challenge, while section 209 simultaneously provides a special amendment procedure encompassing the same provisions.

    This apparent contradiction demands legal clarification.

    More fundamentally, how can a Constitution condemn future unconstitutional seizures of power while permanently protecting those associated with past ones?

    A transitional accommodation may have been necessary for stability. But temporary necessity should not become permanent constitutional privilege.

    The Commander’s submission offers an opportunity for lawful reform, not another constitutional rupture.

    Reconciliation Without Impunity

    Removing immunity must not invite political vengeance.

    The proposed truth, accountability and reconciliation process must be independent, credible and fair. Victims must be heard, evidence examined and responsibility established through due process.

    Grave offences cannot disappear beneath another blanket of immunity. Equally, military service or political association must never become grounds for collective punishment.

    Reconciliation cannot be imposed, and forgiveness cannot be legislated.

    Justice must neither protect yesterday’s powerful nor serve today’s political victors.

    The Vanua and Fiji’s Constitutional Future

    Fiji’s military and political history has a significant iTaukei dimension. But the actions of individual officers must never be confused with the collective aspirations of the iTaukei or the authority of the Vanua.

    The military defends the Republic. Parliament derives authority from the electorate. The Vanua possesses customary legitimacy rooted in land, identity and traditions predating the modern State.

    These responsibilities must remain distinct.

    The BLV’s support for removing immunity demonstrates that indigenous authority and constitutional accountability can reinforce one another.

    A distinctly Fijian democracy must recognise the Vanua without politicising it, respect the military without empowering it to govern, and guarantee equal citizenship without denying the nation’s indigenous foundations.

    These are complementary principles.

    The Legacy We Leave

    The Commander’s submission challenges the RFMF to institutionalise political neutrality and civilian subordination. It challenges Parliament to confront immunity without self-interest, and political leaders to abandon military intervention as a conceivable solution to constitutional disagreement.

    The question of immunity deserves a clear, separate referendum question, allowing citizens to exercise informed judgment.

    Our generation cannot rewrite the history through which it came to leadership. But it can determine what constitutional inheritance it leaves behind.

    If the military is prepared to question the immunity inherited from Fiji’s coups, Parliament should have the courage to question why that immunity must endure.

    The final measure of our service will not be the authority we once exercised, but the limits we had the wisdom to place upon it.

    And perhaps the clearest evidence of constitutional maturity will be when the Constitution, rather than the uniform, unquestionably has the final word.

  • Before You Judge the Vanua, First Understand It

    The debate over the Bose Levu Vakaturaga reveals a deeper question: have we learned to live together without learning to understand one another?

    We speak confidently of multi-culturalism, equal citizenship and national unity. Yet when discussion turns to the BLV, many inhabit different worlds of understanding.

    The issue is not simply whether chiefs have a place in our constitutional arrangements. It is whether those who pronounce upon the Vanua understand the civilisation, language and customary relationships from which its institutions emerged. Language is the most revealing place to begin.

    A Lesson From Kenya

    I lived in Kenya for more than a decade, and the contrast is instructive. Many Kenyans of Indian descent speak Swahili, not because they are inherently more culturally sensitive, but because history, commerce and daily interaction made it a practical bridge between communities. After independence, Swahili also became an instrument of national identity.

    Fiji followed a different path. Colonial policies encouraged communities to develop in largely separate social and linguistic worlds. English became the language of government, law, education and commerce, while Fiji Hindi and vosa vakaViti remained central to our respective communities.

    That inheritance helps explain why many non-iTaukei, including prominent political, business and intellectual figures, can spend their lives in Fiji without acquiring much understanding of vosa vakaViti. But explanation should not become an excuse, particularly for those who seek to influence the affairs of the indigenous people.

    One can read the Constitution, debate customary land or pronounce on chiefly institutions without understanding the relationships and obligations that give the Vanua its meaning. There is a difference between knowing about the iTaukei and understanding the iTaukei.

    Two Understandings of Belonging

    Much of our disagreement arises from different understandings of what it means to belong to a nation. One sees Fiji through a modern civic framework: equal citizenship, individual rights, parliamentary representation and the rule of law. The other also recognises an inherited covenant: the enduring relationship between people, land, ancestry, customary authority and obligations passed between generations.

    For the iTaukei, the Vanua is not simply territory. It embodies identity, belonging, responsibility and continuity.

    These understandings need not contradict each other. Our challenge is to hold both within a constitutional democracy that guarantees equal citizenship while recognising the distinctive place of its indigenous people.

    Respect Is Not Submission

    Nowhere is the gap wider than on the question of chiefs and personal freedom. Two views stand in plain opposition.

    The first begins with the individual. It holds that inherited hierarchy and personal autonomy cannot coexist, and that authority no one has voted for answers to no one. If people can speak for themselves, why do they need chiefs? On this view, the Vanua is a constraint, and the indigenous citizen must eventually choose between his/her chief and his/her own mind.

    The second begins with the relationship. It rejects the choice itself. The Vanua, it says, is not a chain of command but a web of kinship, obligation and service. The people sustain chiefly leadership; chiefs carry duties towards those they serve. Respect is given within that bond, not extracted by force. An iTaukei may honour his chief and still vote against his preferences, and our electoral history shows that indigenous voters do exactly that.

    One view measures freedom by what a person is released from. The other measures it by what a person belongs to. Each hears the other’s vocabulary as either bondage or abandonment, and neither will persuade the other while both speak past it.

    Authority can be misused in any institution, but the possibility of misuse does not invalidate the foundations of the institution itself. An iTaukei should not have to abandon the Vanua to prove his or her independence, any more than any citizen should abandon faith or tradition to prove freedom of thought.

    Multi-culturalism Must Be Reciprocal

    Our leaders frequently speak of multi-culturalism and inclusion. But it cannot mean that indigenous institutions must continually justify their existence while other traditions are accepted as legitimate expressions of identity. Nor should iTaukei be expected to master the language and conventions of modern political and commercial life, while those who wish to influence indigenous affairs feel little obligation to understand the Vanua.

    Reciprocity matters. The iTaukei should understand the history of indenture, the struggles of Indo-Fijians for political equality and the anxieties of our national upheavals. Equally, non-iTaukei citizens, particularly those in positions of influence, should make a serious effort to understand the history, language and customary institutions of the indigenous people.

    This is not a demand for assimilation, nor for fluency in vosa vakaViti before participating in national affairs. It is a call for intellectual humility and cultural curiosity. The business leader negotiating with landowners, the lawyer interpreting customary rights, the academic and the politician debating the BLV should recognise that professional expertise alone does not provide a complete understanding of the Vanua.

    Understanding should precede judgment.

    The BLV Is Not Another Parliament

    The BLV is frequently discussed as though it were a competing political institution. It is not. Its authority does not originate from elections or the government of the day. It comes from the Vanua and the customary relationships that have sustained indigenous society across generations. Its concern is the enduring interests of the iTaukei: cultural inheritance, customary institutions, land and collective wellbeing.

    Governments come and go. Parties rise and fall. Majorities change. The Vanua endures. That is why the BLV’s institutional independence matters: the protection of indigenous identity should not depend solely on the goodwill of whichever party holds office.

    Parliament represents citizens through elections. The BLV embodies a distinct sphere of indigenous customary leadership. These roles need not conflict. The BLV is a shield for the Vanua, not a sword against fellow citizens. Its recognition diminishes neither the citizenship nor the dignity of Indo-Fijians, Rotumans or any other community. It acknowledges that our indigenous civilisation possesses institutions whose legitimacy cannot be measured solely through the ballot box.

    Language Carries a Civilisation

    Vosa vakaViti carries memory, relationships, obligations, authority and ways of understanding the world. Concepts such as Vanua, veiwekani, veirogorogoci, veidokai and veiliutaki cannot be captured by literal English translation. Their meanings emerge through lived relationships and customary practice. Those who discuss the BLV without appreciating them, risk treating a living cultural institution as just another administrative body.

    This matters not because fluency confers wisdom, but because willingness to learn another community’s language often reflects willingness to understand its world. We cannot expect meaningful national dialogue when those most confident in judging indigenous institutions have made little effort to understand their foundations.

    Understanding Before Judgment

    For too long, we have confused co-existence with understanding. We have worked in the same institutions, attended the same schools and voted in the same elections, yet we have not always made the effort to understand how our fellow citizens perceive belonging. The BLV debate exposes that unfinished work.

    Those who declare the institution obsolete should first ask whether they understand its purpose. Those who argue Fiji survived without it under the previous regime, should consider whether administrative survival is an adequate measure of cultural progress. A nation can keep functioning while losing its connection to its historical identity.

    Equal citizenship does not require cultural sameness, and respect for indigenous institutions does not diminish anyone else’s citizenship. We belong to one nation, but our historical journeys differ. Understanding those differences should strengthen our common citizenship, not threaten it.

    Perhaps the most important question is not whether Fiji can survive without its chiefs, but whether it can truly understand itself while unwilling to understand the language, institutions and inherited obligations of the people whose homeland gave the nation its name.

    We have spent generations learning to speak to one another in English. Perhaps it is time we learned to understand one another through the languages and cultures of our shared homeland.

    For the Vanua does not need to justify its existence to those who have yet to understand it.

  • From Gordon Street to the Vanua: Who Owns Fiji Rugby’s Future?

    Fiji has given the rugby world something extraordinary. From village grounds of the Vanua to the great stadiums of Europe, our players show an instinct, courage and brilliance few nations can match.

    Yet an uncomfortable question sits behind that success: how can a country that produces so much talent remain so dependent on others for the resources to develop it? Our talent has travelled the world. The wealth it generates has not always travelled home.

    This is not merely a sporting contradiction. It is a question of economic justice, institutional responsibility and, ultimately, sovereignty.

    The trap of replication

    For generations, the richest rugby economies have benefited from Pasifika talent nurtured in families, schools, villages and provincial competitions. Too often the arrangement has been extractive: talent flows out, while the communities that raised it receive a sliver of the reward.

    We must not recreate that arrangement inside Fiji. If the FRU concentrates investment in elite programmes while treating Vanua unions as mere suppliers of players, we will have swapped one dependency for another. The geography of colonial extraction will have changed. Its logic will not.

    Why fourteen teams matter

    That is why Rewa Rugby Union patron Ro Filipe Tuisawau’s proposal to expand the Skipper Cup to fourteen teams deserves serious consideration. Done properly, expansion widens the foundations of the game: more opportunities for players, coaches, referees and administrators, and more pathways to identify, develop and retain talent. It also recognises that excellence is not the inheritance of a few established unions.

    But expansion without investment is not empowerment. It is the redistribution of hardship. A fourteen-team competition needs a credible funding model, equitable travel arrangements, better facilities, coaching development, and proper medical and welfare support. Otherwise, financially stretched unions will shoulder the cost of national ambitions. That would be neither fair nor sustainable.

    Encouraging signs at Gordon Street

    The appointment of Andrew Durutalo to lead high performance is significant. His statistics-based preview of the Skipper Cup final signaled that domestic rugby deserves the same analytical seriousness as the international game. When provincial players and supporters see their competition treated with respect, the whole domestic game gains.

    But high performance is not statistics, technology or appointments. A sophisticated unit at Gordon Street means little if a promising player in a Vanua union lacks coaching, medical care, nutrition or a viable path to national selection. The measure of reform is not what happens in the boardroom. It is what changes on the ground.

    South Africa offers an instructive, if different, comparison. Jake White’s 2007 World Cup-winning side showed the value of tactical clarity and uncompromising standards, and later generations have shown that widening opportunity can reinforce those standards rather than dilute them. High performance and inclusion are complementary. The FRU’s elite ambitions and Skipper Cup expansion are two halves of one strategy: one raises the standard, the other broadens the foundation.

    Sovereignty needs an economic foundation

    Under Chairman Sanday and CEO Sewabu, the FRU is pursuing development compensation when players join wealthy overseas clubs. The principle is sound: those who invest in developing talent should share in the return. Land and infrastructure projects at Saweni and the Fulton College site could also reduce our reliance on facilities controlled by others.

    But owning infrastructure is not sovereignty. A stadium can be an asset or a burden. Every major investment must answer one question: how will this strengthen the game throughout Fiji, rather than merely the FRU’s balance sheet? Sovereignty cannot mean shifting dependency from overseas institutions to a centralised domestic administration.

    The Vanua is not a supplier

    Behind every outstanding player stand families who sacrificed, teachers who spotted potential, village coaches who volunteered their time, and unions that operated on almost nothing. These contributions never appear in financial statements, yet without them there would be nothing to commercialise.

    That does not exempt provincial unions from professional standards. Accountability must run both ways: the centre invests fairly, and the provinces manage that investment responsibly. That is how trust is built.

    A different measure of success

    Encouragement of the FRU’s leadership must not become unquestioning endorsement. The test of reform will not be agreements signed, property acquired or appointments made. It will be whether provincial unions grow stronger, whether more young Fijians gain real opportunities, and whether the rewards of rugby flow towards the communities that sustain it.

    The ambition of Sanday, Sewabu and Durutalo must meet the grassroots challenge Ro Filipe has set. These are not rival visions. They are two pillars of one national purpose. Fiji Rugby must be commercially capable without becoming commercially captive, and professionally ambitious without becoming institutionally distant.

    Sovereignty does not mean turning our backs on World Rugby, Aotearoa or Australia. It means engaging them from strength, independence and mutual respect. Partnership must not become another word for permanent dependency.

    For decades, Fiji has supplied the world with extraordinary talent. It is time to build a rugby economy to match, one where the communities that produce the players share in the prosperity they create. That is the journey from Gordon Street to the Vanua.

  • When Money Buys Influence and Political Survival Comes Before the Nation

    An extraordinary Haaretz interview with Ronald Lauder, billionaire president of the World Jewish Congress and once a close confidant of Benjamin Netanyahu, offers a sobering lesson for Fiji.

    Lauder alleges that Netanyahu sacrificed a historic opportunity for peace with Syria and Lebanon because it threatened his political future.

    “He chose politics over peace. He put his political future before the deal.”

    Lauder helped advance Netanyahu’s career and negotiated on his behalf. He claims Netanyahu accepted essential peace terms, including withdrawal from the Golan, but ultimately refused to conclude the agreement. Netanyahu disputes this account.

    Nevertheless, the underlying question is profound: What happens when political survival becomes more important than the national interest?

    For Fiji, this is particularly relevant as we consider constitutional reform and changes to political financing.

    Lauder was a wealthy patron whose influence helped Netanyahu’s political ascent. Wealthy citizens have every right to support political candidates. But money can also secure privileged access, amplify political messages, shape policy priorities and create obligations extending beyond elections.

    We see similar concerns here. Some who financially supported FijiFirst now support parties in the governing coalition. Changing political allegiance is legitimate. But when financial support follows political power, citizens are entitled to ask whether principle or access is the greater motivation.

    Lauder’s disillusionment illustrates another truth: wealthy patrons cannot necessarily control the political forces they help elevate. Once established, political power develops its own imperatives. Survival becomes the priority, loyalty the currency, and the national interest risks becoming whatever serves those governing.

    Political financing is therefore not merely administrative. It concerns democracy’s integrity.

    Alongside Constitution (Amendment) Bill No. 32 of 2026, the Government advanced political-financing changes through Bill No. 31.

    The original proposals contemplated removing the annual individual donation ceiling and relaxing restrictions. Parliamentary scrutiny retained the ceiling but increased it from $10,000 to $20,000, introduced campaign expenditure limits and withdrew proposals permitting non-citizen donations.

    These distinctions matter. Nevertheless, the direction deserves scrutiny.

    In Fiji, where many families struggle with living costs, $20,000 is substantial. How many ordinary citizens can afford such contributions? And if major donors enjoy greater access to political leaders, what becomes of political equality?

    Democracy must not become a contest between those who possess votes and those who possess both votes and substantial financial resources.

    Equally concerning is the provision for candidates to disclose donations and expenditure within 60 days after polling. By then, successful candidates will already exercise considerable authority.

    Voters deserve to know who finances candidates before, not merely after, casting their ballots.

    Not every donation is improper. The danger arises when financial support carries expectations of appointments, government contracts, regulatory concessions or privileged access.

    Lauder’s allegations also expose a wider danger. Leaders promise to serve their nations, but some eventually regard remaining in office as indispensable. Opposition becomes disloyalty, scrutiny becomes obstruction, and constitutional safeguards become inconveniences.

    Our history of coups, constitutional ruptures and concentrated executive authority should make us particularly vigilant.

    As we examine constitutional reform, we must ask: Are we strengthening institutions against the misuse of power, or rearranging authority to accommodate those presently exercising it?

    The omission of the CRC’s proposed two-term limit for Prime Ministers deserves scrutiny. No single omission proves improper motives, but constitutional safeguards must be judged by how effectively they restrain future abuses, not how conveniently they serve present leaders.

    Fiji needs independent oversight of political financing, timely disclosure, transparent expenditure reporting, effective auditing and meaningful penalties for concealment. We must guard against donations channelled through intermediaries and conflicts involving public contracts.

    Our traditional institutions, churches and civil society also have responsibilities. Their moral influence must never become a commodity available to the highest bidder.

    The BLV, particularly, must preserve its independence. Its authority comes from the Vanua, not proximity to political power. Independence means being able to offer honest counsel, even when inconvenient.

    Ultimately, Lauder’s account is a warning about the difference between acquiring power and exercising it responsibly.

    Money may help elect governments. Political alliances may keep them in office. Constitutional arrangements may determine their tenure.

    None guarantees that the national interest is being served.

    Fiji should welcome reforms strengthening electoral competition and accountability. But we must resist arrangements allowing financial influence to overwhelm political equality or political survival to take precedence over principle.

    Our democracy must never be for sale, whether openly through campaign contributions or quietly through privileged access and political obligation.

    The ultimate measure of leadership is not how many elections are won or how long power is retained. It is whether those entrusted with authority leave our nation more united, our institutions more independent and our future more secure.

    Lauder’s warning comes after nearly thirty years of silence.

    Fiji should heed its lessons before we have similar reasons for regret.

  • Peace Negotiations as Family Business

    At the heart of the Trump administration’s diplomacy in West Asia and Ukraine lies a troubling question: where do US national interests end and the private interests of those conducting its diplomacy begin?

    Investigative journalist Matthew Cole, in Princes and Thieves, alleges that Jared Kushner, while serving as Trump’s senior adviser, had access to secret accounts associated with Saudi and Emirati interests containing approximately $2 billion. Some funds allegedly supported covert regional operations, while others were reportedly intended for Kushner’s personal benefit.

    Kushner categorically denies these allegations, which remain unproven and unsubstantiated. Can US diplomacy command international confidence while such serious questions about potential conflicts of interest remain unresolved?

    Consider Iran.

    Whatever one thinks of Tehran’s leadership, its negotiators are neither politically naive nor strategically inexperienced. Hardened by decades of sanctions, intelligence operations, and confrontations with successive US administrations, they understand leverage, patience, and national interest.

    Why would they be intimidated by someone whose greatest diplomatic advantage is access to his father-in-law? And why would Russian negotiators, whose intelligence establishments have spent generations studying US vulnerabilities, overlook the possible intersection of personal relationships, commercial interests, and presidential ambitions?

    This does not establish that Kushner lacks negotiating ability or that his present diplomatic activities are compromised. But proximity to power is no substitute for strategic judgment, and presidential access does not automatically confer diplomatic credibility.

    The larger irony is extraordinary.

    In early March, Washington proclaimed military victory over Iran. Yet here we are, at the end of October, with the US preparing for another confrontation with the country it supposedly defeated.

    If the war was won, why must it be fought again? If deterrence was restored, why another military buildup? And if diplomacy is succeeding, why does the region remain on the brink of war?

    These questions expose the danger of confusing military destruction with strategic victory, personal relationships with diplomacy, and transactional dealmaking with sustainable peace.

    Iran has demonstrated resilience without necessarily abandoning its strategic objectives. Neither Tehran nor Moscow is likely to mistake presidential bravado for negotiating leverage. Both understand that wars are not won simply by inflicting the greatest destruction; they are won by achieving political objectives.

    For smaller nations, including those of us in the Pasifika, the lesson is equally important.

    We must never confuse the spectacle of great-power diplomacy with its substance. Issues negotiated around personal ambition and private interests risk becoming a temporary bargain.

    When such bargains collapse, it is we who bear the consequences.

    The measure of a peace negotiator is not access to the President or to billionaires, but the credibility, judgment, and strategic understanding required to deliver lasting peace.

    And so the most disturbing question remains: Are we witnessing diplomacy intended to prevent another war, or diplomacy preparing the political justification for one?

    And if peace becomes a family business, whose interests are ultimately being served?

  • A Distinctly Fiji Democracy: The Reset Our Nation Needs

    Fifty-six years after independence, Fiji is still wrestling with questions that should have been confronted in 1970. Who are we as a nation? How do we reconcile our itaukei foundations with equal citizenship? What place should our traditional institutions occupy in a modern democracy? And how do we ensure that constitutional power serves the people rather than those temporarily entrusted with government?

    These questions have followed us through independence, coups, constitutional upheavals and repeated promises of reconciliation. They will not disappear simply because we rewrite a preamble or rearrange the composition of a select committee.

    A distinctly Fiji democracy may be the reset our nation requires.

    But that reset must speak honestly to anxieties on all sides: to those who fear that indigenous recognition may become a justification for permanent privilege, and to those who fear that equal citizenship may become a pretext for cultural displacement.

    The principle of equal citizenship is indispensable. Fiji belongs to all its citizens. No one should feel like a guest in their own country. Every citizen deserves equal dignity, equal protection of the law and a government accountable to all.

    Nothing in a distinctly Fiji democracy should compromise those principles.

    But equal citizenship does not require us to pretend that history began yesterday. Nor does it require us to regard the Vanua as merely another interest group, or the Deed of Cession as a historical relic with no bearing on the legitimacy of the modern State.

    The Vanua existed before colonial government. Its relationships, obligations, leadership and customary authority were not inventions of British administration. Colonialism reorganised and regulated many of them, but it did not create the iTaukei relationship with their land and sea.

    That relationship is more than a commercial transaction. It encompasses ancestry, identity, kinship, spiritual continuity and obligations to generations yet unborn.

    Recognising itaukei foundations do not diminish anyone else’s citizenship. It acknowledges that our constitutional order rests upon a history that predates the State itself.

    Yet recognition must mean more than ceremonial respect or constitutional reassurance.

    Consider customary land and resources. We rightly proclaim that iTaukei land ownership is protected. But ownership and control are not necessarily the same. Indigenous landowners hold customary title but remain constrained in determining how their land is administered, developed and used for economic advancement.

    A people should not remain perpetual spectators to development upon their ancestral land.

    Disagreements over customary boundaries and resource entitlements are real. They require fair adjudication, clear procedures and accountable institutions. But disunity does not extinguish ownership, any more than disagreement between political parties extinguishes democracy.

    Complexity is a reason to strengthen governance, not an excuse to perpetuate the inherited assumption, that the State always know better.

    The same principle applies to the Bose Levu Vakaturaga.

    Its constitutional recognition should reflect its enduring responsibility to safeguard the well-being, identity and collective interests of the Vanua. Its independence must not depend upon the goodwill of successive governments.

    But constitutional protection carries corresponding responsibilities. The BLV must exercise its authority in service of the people, respecting the proprietary rights of mataqali and other customary landowning communities.

    Protecting the institutions of the Vanua must never become a substitute for empowering the people of the Vanua.

    Critics rightly warn that traditional institutions can become instruments of elite privilege, where leaders speak in the people’s name while those they represent remain impoverished or unheard. That danger must be acknowledged, not dismissed.

    But accountability does not mean subordinating customary institutions to a State that disregards indigenous history. It means ensuring that authority remains answerable to those it exists to serve.

    This is equally relevant to chiefly succession.

    Tradition is not static. Leadership grounded in courage, wisdom, humility and service is not a rejection of tradition but an affirmation of its highest ideals. Hereditary lineage may establish chiefly entitlement, but it does not automatically confer mana or command respect.

    A chief’s standing must ultimately be sustained through relationships, service and the confidence of the people. When succession becomes disconnected from those obligations, the institution itself is weakened.

    A mature Fiji democracy should be capable of examining such questions without treating every discussion of traditional leadership as an attack upon the Vanua.

    Yet indigenous recognition alone cannot resolve our constitutional difficulties.

    A distinctly Fiji democracy must be uncompromising about constitutional supremacy, the rule of law and accountability.

    We must confront the legacy of coups, sweeping immunity provisions, political interference in public institutions and the temptation to treat constitutional reform as an exercise in political convenience.

    A Constitution should restrain power, not merely distribute it. It should protect institutional independence, guarantee meaningful public participation and provide effective remedies when rights are violated.

    It must also look beyond electoral cycles. National development, education, environmental stewardship and the well-being of future generations require continuity of purpose that no single government can provide.

    Our troubled history demands equal honesty.

    The coups of 1987 and 2000 inflicted suffering, particularly upon Indo-Fijians who were targeted, displaced or made to feel insecure in their own country. Those experiences cannot be dismissed through appeals to indigenous tradition.

    But the iTaukei experience also deserves examination. Those coups were justified in the name of indigenous protection. Yet what did ordinary iTaukei ultimately gain?

    We inherited weakened institutions, fractured communities, damaged investor confidence and diminished trust. Genuine anxieties over land, identity and political security were exploited, while the promised benefits often failed to reach those in whose name power was seized.

    Fiji cannot move beyond competing grievances without acknowledging both experiences.

    The Deed of Cession remains part of our historical foundation. Independence did not erase that history, but neither can its obligations be resolved simply by invoking documents written more than 150 years ago.

    They demand honest examination within the realities of a modern, multiracial democracy.

    We cannot turn back the clock, nor should we. But neither should we mistake the passage of time for the resolution of history.

    The answer is not to reject democracy, constitutional supremacy or equal citizenship. It is to ask whether we have sufficiently adapted those principles to our history, customary institutions, cultural diversity and shared aspirations.

    As former Chief Justice Daniel Fatiaki reminded the Constitution Review Commission: *Vox Populi Est Suprema Lex* — the voice of the people is the supreme law.

    That principle should guide our constitutional renewal.

    Not the convenience of a coalition. Not the inherited assumptions of colonial administration. Certainly not the ambitions of individual leaders.

    And the voice of the people must mean all the people — not one community, political party or institution speaking on behalf of everyone else.

    Fifty-six years after independence, perhaps our greatest unfinished task is to develop the confidence to build a constitutional democracy authentically our own.

    One that recognises our iTaukei foundations without diminishing anyone’s citizenship. One that respects tradition without placing it beyond accountability. One that protects rights without fearing their exercise. And one that understands national unity not as the absence of differences, but as the capacity to govern those differences with justice, wisdom and mutual respect.

    Independence gave us the right to govern ourselves. A distinctly Fiji democracy may finally give us the constitutional confidence to do so on our own terms.

  • “Only Exploration”: When Legal Excuses Replace Good Judgment

    The Minister’s defense is legally tidy but democratically hollow. Saying “no mining licence has been issued” and “this is only exploration” hides behind a convenient distinction while avoiding the real question: should exploration have been contemplated at all?

    The Sigatoka Sand Dunes are no ordinary coastline. They are national heritage—archaeologically significant, ecologically sensitive, culturally valuable—not mere sand deposits awaiting commercial assessment. That distinction should count before any exploration application is entertained.

    Exploration is not an innocent prelude. It is a consequential decision: drilling, sampling, access roads, disturbance, commercial expectations. Telling citizens not to worry because only a special prospecting licence is sought, is like telling a homeowner not to mind the bulldozer outside because its engine has not started. The machinery is there; the intention is clear.

    What is troubling is the condescension in the Minister’s reassurance that “proper processes” must be followed. Of course they must. That is Government’s obligation, not a concession. Fijians do not need a lecture on procedure. They deserve an explanation of why an application affecting environment, livelihoods, cultural heritage and national inheritance reached this stage without meaningful public engagement.

    The procedural defense sidesteps a larger question: are there places whose ecological, archaeological and cultural significance should place them beyond extractive exploration altogether? If the Sigatoka Sand Dunes do not warrant that consideration, what does? The dunes cannot be separated from the river, coastline, communities and interconnected ecosystems. Disturbance does not respect lines on a prospecting map. Archaeological treasures, once destroyed, cannot be restored by an environmental management plan.

    This is where the precautionary principle matters. Where consequences may be irreversible, the burden should fall on those proposing intervention to show why it should even be considered—not on communities to prove why it should be stopped. Yet development too often reverses that responsibility: commercial interests initiate, agencies administer, communities mobilise to protect what they inherited.

    The public is not an inconvenience to be managed bureaucratically. Communities should not discover proposals affecting their future after government machinery has begun turning. Consultation beginning after decisions acquire momentum is notification dressed up as participation. Caught off guard by backlash, the Government retreats behind the narrowest legal distinction: prospecting is not mining. Technically correct but, politically evasive and democratically inadequate.

    In a distinctly Fiji democracy, public participation should be foundational, not an afterthought. The real question is not whether a mining licence has been issued, but whether a special prospecting license should have been entertained without first establishing environmental, archaeological and cultural implications and engaging genuinely with traditional landowners, local communities and stakeholders.

    An EIA matters, but it cannot substitute for sound judgment at the outset. Nor should it become a mechanism through which a questionable proposal gains legitimacy because boxes have been ticked. A process can be legally compliant and still produce an unwise decision. That is the distinction the Minister seems unwilling to acknowledge.

    Some places deserve protection not because their commercial potential is exhausted but because their value transcends commercial calculation. Responsible government is measured not by how efficiently it processes applications, but by how wisely it decides which activities should be entertained at all.

    If the process is as transparent as claimed, publish the application, exploration plans, maps, environmental baseline information and consultation records. Suspend consideration pending independent scrutiny and meaningful engagement with affected communities. If scrutiny establishes unacceptable risks to an irreplaceable inheritance, reject the application. Not defer it. Not repackage it. Reject it.

    Public opposition is not necessarily hostility to development. It may reflect an informed recognition that development has limits and some losses cannot be compensated by royalties, employment promises or corporate assurances.

    Good governance is not merely following the law. It is exercising public authority with wisdom, humility and respect for those who live with its consequences. Public trust is not secured by explaining what Government is legally entitled to do. It is earned by showing that Government understands what it is morally obliged to protect.

    The Sigatoka Sand Dunes have survived generations. Our responsibility is to ensure they survive generations yet unborn. The Minister may be satisfied no mining licence has been issued. Citizens are entitled to ask why disturbing such a precious inheritance was entertained at all. That is precisely the question a responsible Government should have asked before the public had to.

    Not everything beneath our feet needs to be dug up to establish its worth. Some things are valuable precisely because we have the wisdom to leave them undisturbed.

  • The Vanua and the Civic Contract: Why iTaukei and Indo-Fijians Speak Past Each Other

    There is an enduring paradox in our islands that deserves honest reflection.

    The iTaukei have historically maintained deep relationships with other Pasifika communities. We share cultural affinities with Rotumans, our Melanesian Wantok brothers and sisters, Banabans on Rabi, Tuvaluans on Kioa, and our neighbours in Tonga and Samoa and beyond. Despite differences in language and custom, we often understand one another instinctively.

    Yet after nearly 150 years of living together, why do iTaukei and Indo-Fijians still so frequently speak past each other on questions of identity, belonging and nationhood?

    The answer lies in two different understandings of belonging. For many Indo-Fijians, Fiji is understood primarily through a modern civic contract: a nation of equal citizens governed by common laws, individual rights and democratic institutions. For many iTaukei, Fiji is also an inherited covenant: an ancestral relationship between people, land, sea, customary institutions and generations yet unborn.

    Both understandings contain essential truths. Our difficulty begins when either is treated as sufficient on its own.

    Indigeneity Is Not Simply Ethnicity

    At the heart of this misunderstanding is a distinction our current constitutional debates often neglect. Indigeneity is not merely an ethnicity, another demographic category competing for resources. It is an ancestral relationship between a people, their Vanua, customary institutions, language and the land and sea from which their civilisation emerged.

    That relationship predates the modern State. When the Deed of Cession was signed in 1874, the chiefs were not surrendering empty territory. They represented existing communities with their own systems of governance, customary laws and proprietary relationships. The colonial State encountered an existing indigenous civilisation; that civilisation did not emerge because the State recognised it.

    The historical legitimacy of the Vanua must provide the context within which contemporary constitutional safeguards are conceived. Otherwise, what existed before the State risks becoming a privilege dependent upon the goodwill of successive governments. Equal citizenship must be affirmed. But equal citizenship cannot erase prior indigenous belonging, nor should indigenous recognition diminish anyone else’s dignity. Fiji belongs to all its citizens; its indigenous foundations are an inseparable part of its constitutional inheritance.

    Two Histories, One Country

    Many Pasifika communities share a worldview where land is more than property. It represents ancestry, belonging and continuity. Our fellow Melanesians, Polynesians and Micronesians, have their own experiences of customary authority. Their histories are not identical to ours, but they provide a familiar language through which to understand the Vanua. Concepts such as veiwekani, veilomani and solesolevaki, express responsibilities extending beyond the individual.

    But we should not romanticise these differences. Indo-Fijians also possess profound traditions of family, community, spirituality and ancestral memory. The difference is not that one community possesses culture and another does not. It is that our communities experienced Fiji’s history from different starting points.

    The iTaukei experienced colonialism as an indigenous people whose homeland came under external sovereignty. Indo-Fijians experienced colonialism largely through indenture, migration, and the struggle to establish a permanent home. These experiences produced different anxieties. For iTaukei, the fear is that modern equality may become a means of diminishing indigenous identity and historical rights. For Indo-Fijians, the fear is that indigenous recognition may justify political exclusion. Neither anxiety should be dismissed.

    The coups of 1987 and 2000 remain part of the Indo-Fijian historical experience and cannot be explained away by invoking the Vanua. Equally, the iTaukei experience of colonial disruption and threats to customary authority cannot be dismissed as nostalgia. We cannot demand empathy for our own history while refusing it to others.

    The BLV: Beyond the Shadows of the Past

    Nowhere is this misunderstanding more evident than in discussions about the Bose Levu Vakaturaga. For some Indo-Fijians, the BLV remains associated with earlier political controversies. Those concerns deserve acknowledgment. But institutions must be judged by what they are becoming, not only by what they once were.

    The restored BLV operates in a different environment. Many traditional leaders today possess professional qualifications and international experience. Yet education alone does not confer wisdom. Among the iTaukei, we often hear, “Na Turaga sa mai vua na Kalou”—that chiefly authority comes from God. But chieftainship and mana must never be confused. Lineage may establish customary standing, but respect must be earned through humility, integrity and service.

    The restored BLV must demonstrate independence from party politics and accountability to the Vanua. Its constitutional standing should protect its essential composition and independence from political interference, but independence must never mean immunity from scrutiny. The BLV should be a customary pillar within Fiji’s constitutional order—neither subordinate to the government of the day nor superior to the State. It must be a shield for the Vanua, not a sword against other citizens.

    The Covenant Must Have Practical Meaning

    Recognition cannot end with ceremonial respect. The Deed of Cession of 1874 established a relationship whose significance extends beyond the transfer of sovereignty.

    Consider Queen Victoria’s undertaking conveyed to the chiefs at Nailaga in 1881 concerning customary rights over reefs—a promise that measures would be taken to secure to each mataqali, the reefs that properly belonged to it. Nearly a century later, the BLV established a committee at Tubou in 1978 to examine fishing rights and foreshore ownership. The resulting 1978-79 report concluded that existing arrangements did not adequately reflect these earlier undertakings, recommending recognition of indigenous proprietary rights over reefs and foreshore.

    These are not merely episodes in colonial history. They raise an enduring question: how should historical undertakings inform the laws by which we govern today? The present legal position must be understood within that historical context. There is a difference between what the law presently provides and what historical justice may still require.

    For the Vanua, land and qoliqoli are not merely economic assets. They embody responsibilities to ancestors and generations yet unborn. A distinctly Fiji democracy should be sufficiently mature to examine inherited obligations without defensiveness, and confident enough to address unresolved questions through law and justice.

    A Distinctly Fiji Democracy

    My years in international service taught me an enduring lesson: understanding must precede judgment. Whenever I assumed a new leadership responsibility, I first sought to understand what my predecessors had built. Leadership is about building upon foundations, not dismantling them for the satisfaction of starting afresh.

    Fiji cannot construct a durable constitutional future by treating its indigenous foundations as obstacles to modernity. Equally, we cannot build national unity by expecting Indo-Fijians or other communities to accept anything less than equal dignity and protection under the law.

    We need a distinctly Fiji democracy. Not chiefly rule. Not ethnic domination. Not an imported democratic template stripped of our history. Rather, a constitutional settlement combining universal rights and equal citizenship with meaningful recognition of indigenous identity and collective responsibilities.

    Our political leaders must move beyond negotiating thresholds in Parliament. They must listen in villages, settlements, farms, temples, churches and mosques. Indo-Fijians should be able to understand the Vanua without feeling their citizenship is diminished. iTaukei should be able to affirm indigenous identity without questioning the legitimate belonging of fellow citizens.

    Neither community should have to surrender its history to secure its future. The civic contract and the indigenous covenant need not compete. Our children should inherit a Fiji where indigenous recognition is not mistaken for discrimination, and equal citizenship is not mistaken for indigenous erasure.

    We have spent too many decades speaking past each other. Perhaps it is time we began listening—not merely to answer, but to understand.

    Same ocean. Same shore. Same storm. One ship. And it is time we learned to sail it together.

  • Indigeneity Is Not an Ethnicity: Not One Group Among Many

    Equal citizenship does not erase the prior belonging of an indigenous people.

    Indigeneity reaches back to time immemorial. Colonial rule arrived in Fiji barely 150 years ago. Yet somewhere in our pursuit of a modern, inclusive nation, we seem to be forgetting a fundamental truth.

    Indigeneity is not merely an ethnicity. It is not simply one demographic category among many, to be balanced, diluted or redefined at the convenience of the state.

    It is something far more profound: an ancestral and enduring relationship between a people, their vanua, their institutions and the land and sea from which their identity and civilisation emerged.

    It is a relationship that existed before the modern state — and one whose legitimacy does not depend upon the state’s recognition.

    For the iTaukei, this rests upon four fundamental truths.

    First, we were here before the state.

    We did not arrive as settlers within an established colonial order. Our ancestors developed their own systems of governance, chiefly authority, customary law, language and social organisation, rooted in the vanua. These institutions preceded the Deed of Cession of 1874. They were not creations of colonialism, nor are they merely competing claims within the constitutional order that subsequently emerged.

    They are among the foundations upon which that order was built.

    Second, the state came to us.

    The Deed of Cession was not Fiji joining the world. In a profound historical sense, it was the colonial world coming to Fiji — encountering an existing indigenous civilisation and assuming obligations towards its people, their welfare and their institutions.

    Those obligations cannot simply be dismissed as historical inconveniences.

    Nor did the modern state create the identity of the indigenous Fijian. The name Fijian was historically associated with the indigenous people long before it was adopted as a common national designation.

    The state came after the people, not the people after the state.

    Third, indigeneity does not exclude others, but neither can it be extinguished by equality.

    Every citizen of Fiji deserves equal dignity, equal protection under the law and an equal stake in our country’s future. That principle should be beyond dispute.

    But equal citizenship and indigenous belonging are not interchangeable concepts.

    Citizenship is a relationship between the individual and the state. Indigeneity is an ancestral relationship between a people and their homeland, extending across generations and predating the state itself.

    One can be shared without extinguishing the other.

    Fiji is our common nation. The vanua remains the ancestral foundation of the iTaukei. The name Fijian may now express our shared citizenship, but its indigenous historical roots must not be forgotten or detached from the people from whom that identity originated.

    Fourth, indigeneity is collective, inherited and enduring.

    Governments may change. Constitutions may be amended. Political institutions may be abolished or restored.

    But a people cannot be legislated out of their ancestral existence.

    Our indigeneity lives in the vanua, in our customary lands and qoliqoli, in our vosa vakaViti, in our chiefly institutions and in the Bose Levu Vakaturaga. These are not merely cultural ornaments to be preserved for ceremonial occasions. They are living expressions of our collective identity, continuity and authority.

    This is why the constitutional removal of the BLV, or the characterisation of indigenous protections as privileges to be weighed against equality, cuts so deeply.

    It is not simply a political disagreement. It is a question of our very being — of who we are, where we come from, and whether our ancestral relationship with Fiji can be made conditional upon the political preferences of the day.

    When indigeneity is reduced to ethnicity, and ancestral rights are treated as concessions granted by the state, the relationship is inverted.

    What existed before the state becomes dependent upon the state for its legitimacy.

    That is the fundamental contradiction we must confront.

    None of this diminishes the belonging of other communities whose histories, sacrifices and contributions have helped shape modern Fiji. Their place in our nation is real, legitimate and deserving of equal respect.

    But inclusion should never require indigenous erasure. Nor should national unity demand that the first people surrender the distinctiveness of their ancestral belonging.

    A confident, distinctly Fiji democracy should be capable of embracing both truths: equal citizenship for all and enduring constitutional recognition of the indigenous people.

    That is why indigeneity must be expressly recognised in our supreme law, alongside the institutions, customary relationships and collective rights through which it finds expression.

    For recognition left to sentiment alone is precarious. Political goodwill can change with governments. Constitutional recognition provides a more enduring safeguard.

    Ultimately, the question is not whether Fiji belongs to all its citizens as a modern nation. It does.

    The deeper question is whether, in affirming that shared belonging, we are prepared to honour the indigenous foundations upon which our nationhood rests.

    Our future must be shared. But our shared future must not be purchased at the price of indigenous forgetting.

    Indigeneity is not a privilege bestowed by the state.

    It is a truth the state inherited, a covenant history entrusted to us, and a responsibility our Constitution must honour.

  • When Giants Play Chess, the Pasifika Must Not Become the Board

    As China and the West compete for influence, Pasifika Island nations must defend our sovereignty, preserve our friendships and unite against the greatest threat to our survival.

    An intriguing argument has emerged from the war with Iran. Arnaud Bertrand contends that China, by sharply reducing oil imports, inadvertently helped avert global economic catastrophe. US military power disrupted West Asia; China’s economic resilience cushioned the consequences. The claim may be arguable, but the lesson matters for the Pasifika: military superiority no longer guarantees strategic success. Economic resilience, energy independence and capacity to withstand shocks increasingly determine national power.

    For the Pasifika, this raises an uncomfortable question: as great powers compete for dominance, whose security are we being asked to protect, and at what cost to our own?

    The Pasifika Is Not Anyone’s Chessboard

    The contest is familiar. China expands economic, diplomatic and security ties. The US, Australia and Western partners respond with strategic attention, defense cooperation and warnings about Beijing. Each presents its engagement as beneficial. Yet we must distinguish their priorities from ours. Washington views the Pasifika through competition with China. Beijing seeks influence and chances to challenge Western dominance. Canberra sees its immediate national security interests. These concerns are understandable, but they are not necessarily our priorities, nor Vanuatu’s, Samoa, Tonga, Solomon Islands or our wider Pasifika family. We must resist becoming instruments of another country’s calculations. We cannot exchange one dependency for another, or mistake diplomatic attention for respect for our sovereignty.

    Friends to All, Subservient to None

    Our aspiration to be friends to all and enemies to none is dismissed as naïve. It is not. For small states, constructive relationships with competing powers preserve choices, diversify opportunities and reduce our vulnerability. But friendship must never mean unquestioning accommodation. Chinese investment deserves consideration alongside concerns about debt, transparency and strategic dependency. Equally, security cooperation with Australia, America and traditional partners must serve our interests, not merely historical loyalties. No foreign power should acquire privileged influence over our sovereign decisions or draw us into conflicts unrelated to our security. The test of genuine friendship is whether a powerful partner respects our right to disagree with it.

    Our Greatest Security Threat Is Not a Foreign Warship

    Here lies the contradiction. Great powers define security through military access, naval deployments, intelligence cooperation and containment. Yet our greatest existential threat is not an invading army. It is climate change. Rising seas threaten ancestral lands. Coastal erosion displaces communities. Intensifying cyclones destroy infrastructure. Ocean warming threatens fisheries, livelihoods and food security. The irony is that the powers competing here are among the world’s largest historical or current emitters. They offer military assistance while emissions driving our insecurity continue. They speak of defending sovereignty while rising seas threaten the territories upon which sovereignty rests. What value is a security guarantee if our islands become uninhabitable? Climate justice is not an add-on to security; it is security.

    From Nadi to Istanbul: One Pasifika Voice

    With the pre-COP31 meeting in Nadi concluded and delegations preparing for Istanbul, our challenge is clear. Pasifika states should unite under the PIF umbrella, bringing one disciplined regional voice. Fragmented diplomacy is untenable when collective survival is at stake. Governments must insist on meaningful emissions reductions, accessible climate finance, loss-and-damage commitments and accountability from major emitters. China, America, Australia and Europe must hear the same message: Pasifika security cannot be separated from climate justice. Our collective voice carries greater weight than isolated appeals. Istanbul must not become another gathering where the powerful negotiate while small island concerns are drowned out. The Blue Pasifika must speak for itself.

    The Sovereignty We Must Defend

    The lesson from China’s energy resilience is not to embrace Beijing over Washington. It is that genuine security begins with reducing vulnerability. For the Pasifika, that means renewable energy, climate-resilient infrastructure, stronger institutions and collective diplomatic independence. We should welcome cooperation from every responsible partner, but never surrender our priorities for patronage. The Iran war reminds us that great powers can start conflicts without controlling consequences; small states often bear those consequences without sharing the decisions. We cannot control Washington’s or Beijing’s ambitions. We can determine how we engage. Friends to all, pawns of none.

    Ultimately, Pasifika security will not be measured by whose warships patrol our waters, but by whether our children and grandchildren can live with dignity and sovereignty on the lands and oceans of their ancestors. 

    That is the future worth defending.